INTRODUCTION
Lymphedema is one of the relevant complications that occur in the postoperative
period of patients undergoing a surgical procedure for the treatment of cancer,
resulting from the concentration of fluid in the interstitium, with a large
protein cluster motivated by disorders of the lymphatic circulation that
affects, above all, the upper limbs1. Lymphedema in post-mastectomy patients occurs in around 20%
to 30% of cases, with a prevalence rate of 15% to 30%1-3.
Patients who undergo mastectomy must be treated postoperatively by a
physiotherapist. This professional aims to control postoperative pain, prevent
or treat lymphedema and postural changes, promote muscle relaxation, maintain
the range of motion of the upper limb involved, and improve the appearance and
malleability of the scar, preventing or treating adhesions1,4. One of the physiotherapist’s interventions is complex
decongestive therapy, which consists of four approaches: guidance on skin care,
manual lymphatic drainage, compressive bandaging, and lymphomyokinetic exercises
- all to reduce lymphedema2-4.
For the physiotherapist to provide guidance, it is necessary to have
technical-scientific knowledge and to develop educational resources and
technologies (applications, electronic games, online courses, electronic medical
records) with low cost, greater effectiveness, ease, and accessibility to the
population5,6.
Several studies have shown that applications have been developed to provide care
and guide clinical decisions. These are validated studies and results of
research-based recommendations for practice5-7. Building an app
for mobile devices offers professionals, caregivers, and patients a quick way
to
consult. It is easily transported to the various practice settings in healthcare
facilities. It is hoped that doubts are resolved when accessing this tool and
that there is more autonomy, both in the execution of physiotherapy exercises
and in the control of clinical evolution8-14.
Developing an application aimed at post-mastectomized patients with upper limb
lymphedema (UL) is unprecedented in Physiotherapy. It is an approach of great
scientific and social relevance insofar as it provides accessibility to specific
forms of care and ensures easy access to information and control of patients’
evolution. The developed application is evident as a new therapeutic path in
the
area of rehabilitation of mastectomized patients.
OBJECTIVE
Therefore, this study aimed to build an application for preventing and treating
upper limb lymphedema.
METHODS
The study applied the technological production modality of the methodological
development research type to construct an application for the prevention and
treatment of UL lymphedema in post-mastectomized patients, entitled ”Linfedema
APP.”
As an application development methodology, Contextualized Instructional Design
(CID) was chosen, which involves a constructivist proposal and consists of the
intentional action of planning, developing, and applying specific didactic
situations, incorporating mechanisms that favor contextualization15.
The construction of the application took place in four stages, including
conception, elaboration of the content, construction of the application, and
performance of functionality tests.
The study design involved understanding the educational problem and devising a
related solution. A previous search was carried out to verify the existence of
applications that guide the physiotherapist in evaluating, preventing, and
treating upper limb lymphedema in post-mastectomized patients.
After verifying the problem’s existence, an integrative literature review was
carried out in the Health Sciences databases, including the Cochrane Library,
SciELO, LILACS, and MEDLINE, using as descriptors lymphedema and
physiotherapy.
For the selection of publications to be included in the review, two basic axes
were adopted as inclusion criteria: only primary studies that were directly
linked to the theme to be available in full and without proposed temporal
delimitation, as the intention was to compile all studies that met the
established criteria. Book chapters, theses, dissertations, monographs,
technical reports, reference works, and articles that, after reading the
abstract, did not converge with the proposed object of study, and publications
that were repeated in the databases and virtual library were excluded.
After reading the abstracts, articles that described the descriptors lymphedema
and physiotherapy were selected. Based on this survey, an application was
created to treat and prevent post-mastectomized patients with upper limb
lymphedema (Figure 1 and Chart 1).
Chart 1 - Characteristics of the studies selected for the application for
treating post-mastectomized patients with upper limb lymphedema.
Author |
Title |
Periodic.
Year; Volume (Number): Page
|
Howell DM, et al. |
Complete decongestive therapy for lymphedema
following breast cancer treatment (Protocol).
|
Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2009 |
Carvalho APF
& Azevedo EMM
|
Estudo
comparativo entre a fisioterapia aquática e a convencional para
reduzir linfedema pós-tratamento cirúrgico de câncer de mama:
ensaio clínico randomizado / Comparative study between the
aquatic physiotherapy and the conventional for lymphedema
reduction after surgical treatment for breast cancer: randomized
clinical trial
|
Rev Bras
Mastologia. 2009;19(4):133-40
|
Forner-Cordero I, et al. |
Predictive Factors of Response to Decongestive
Therapy in Patients with Breast-Cancer-Related Lymphedem
|
Ann Surg Oncol. 2010;17(3):744-51 |
Soares HPS, et
al.
|
Complex
decongestant therapy with use of alternative material to reduce
and control lymphedema in patients with endemic area of
filariasis: a clinical trial
|
Fisioter Pesqui.
2016;23(3):268-77
|
Kim DS, et al. |
Effect of active resistive exercise on breast
cancer-related lymphedema: a randomized controlled trial
|
Arch Phys Med Rehabil. 2010;91(12):1844-8 |
Hacard F, et al. |
Measurement of
skin thickness and skin elasticity to evaluate the effectiveness
of intensive decongestive treatment in patients with
lymphoedema: a prospective study
|
Skin Res Technol.
2014;20(3):274-81
|
Kasseroller RG & Brenner E |
A prospective randomised study of alginate-drenched
low stretch bandages as an alternative to conventional
lymphologic compression bandaging
|
Support Care Cancer. 2010;18(3):343-50 |
Karafa M, et al. |
The effect of
different compression pressure in therapy of secondary upper
extremity lymphedema in women after breast cancer surgery
|
Lymphology.
2018;51(1):28-37
|
Melam GR, et al. |
Effect of complete decongestive therapy and home
program on healthrelated quality of life in post mastectomy
lymphedema patients
|
BMC Womens Health. 2016;16(1):16-23 |
Bozkurt M, et al. |
Effectiveness of
Decongestive Lymphatic Therapy in Patients with Lymphedema
Resulting from Breast Cancer Treatment Regardless of Previous
Lymphedema Treatment
|
Breast J.
2017;23(2):154-8
|
Tambour M, et al. |
Manual lymphatic drainage adds no further volume
reduction to Complete Decongestive Therapy on breast
cancer-related lymphoedema: a multicentre, randomised,
single-blind trial
|
Br J Cancer. 2018;119(1):1215-22 |
Melgaard D |
What is the
effect of treating secondary lymphedema after breast cancer with
complete decongestive physiotherapy when the bandage is replaced
with Kinesio Textape? - A pilot study
|
Physiother Theory
Pract. 2016;32(6):446-51
|
Dayes IS, et al. |
Randomized Trial of Decongestive Lymphatic Therapy
for the Treatment of Lymphedema in Women With Breast Cancer
|
J Clin Oncol. 2013;31(30):3758-63 |
Park JH |
The effects of
complex exercise on shoulder range of motion and pain for women
with breast cancer-related lymphedema: a single-blind,
randomized controlled trial
|
Breast Cancer.
2017;24(4):608-14
|
Oliveira MMF, et al. |
Long term effects of manual lymphatic drainage and
active exercises on physical morbidities, lymphoscintigraphy
parameters and lymphedema formation in patients operated due to
breast cancer: a clinical trial
|
PLoS One. 2018;13(1):e0189176 |
Haghighat S, et
al.
|
Comparing two
treatment methods for post mastectomy lymphedema: complex
decongestive therapy alone and in combination with intermittent
pneumatic compression
|
Lymphology.
2010;43(1):25-33
|
Gatt M, et al. |
A meta-analysis of the effectiveness and safety of
kinesiology taping in the management of cancer-related
lymphoedema
|
Eur J Cancer Care (Engl). 2017;26(5):1-13 |
Uzkeser H, et al. |
Efficacy of
manual lymphatic drainage and intermittent pneumatic compression
pump use in the treatment of lymphedema after mastectomy: a
randomized controlled trial
|
Breast Cancer.
2015;22(3):300-7
|
Mestre S, et al. |
Interest of an auto-adjustable nighttime
compression sleeve (MOBIDERM® Autofit) in maintenance
phase of upper limb lymphedema: the MARILYN pilot RC
|
Support Care Cancer. 2017;25(8):2455-62 |
Kizil R, et al. |
Is Continuous
Passive Motion Effective in Patients with Lymphedema? A
Randomized Controlled Trial
|
Lymphat Res Biol.
2018;16(3):263-9
|
Szoinoky G, et al. |
Intermittent pneumatic compression acts
synergistically with manual lymphatic drainage in complex
decongestive physiotherapy for breast cancer treatment-related
lymphedema
|
Lymphology. 2009;42(4):188-94 |
Cacchio A, et al. |
Effectiveness and
safety of a product containing diosmin, coumarin, and arbutin
(Linfadren®) in addition to complex decongestive
therapy on management of breast cancer-related lymphedema
|
Support Care
Cancer. 2019;27(4):1471-80
|
Gradalski T, et al. |
Complex Decongestive Lymphatic Therapy With or
Without Vodder II Manual Lymph Drainage in More Severe Chronic
Postmastectomy Upper Limb Lymphedema: A Randomized
Non-Inferiority Prospective Study
|
J Pain Symptom Manage. 2015;50(6):750-7 |
Do JH, et al. |
Effects of a
complex rehabilitation program on edema status, physical
function, and quality of life in lower-limb lymphedema after
gynecological cancer surgery
|
Gynecol Oncol.
2017;147(2):450-5
|
Abbasi B, et al. |
The effect of relaxation techniques on edema,
anxiety and depression in post-mastectomy lymphedema patients
undergoing comprehensive decongestive therapy: A clinical trial
|
PLoS One. 2018;13(1):e0190231 |
Ergin G, et al. |
Effects of
Aqua-Lymphatic Therapy on Lower Extremity Lymphedema: A
Randomized Controlled Study
|
Res Biol.
2017;15(3):284-91
|
Vignes S, et al. |
Intensive complete decongestive physiotherapy for
cancer-related upper-limb lymphedema: 11 days achieved greater
volume reduction than 4
|
Gynecol Oncol. 2013;131(1):127-30 |
Pekyavaş NÖ, et
al.
|
Complex
decongestive therapy and taping for patients with postmastectomy
lymphedema: A randomized controlled study
|
Eur J Oncol Nurs.
2014;18(6):585-90
|
Bok SK, et al. |
Ultrasonographic Evaluation of the Effects of
Progressive Resistive Exercise in Breast Cancer-Related
Lymphedem
|
Lymphat Res Biol. 2016;14(1):18-24 |
Ha KJ, et
al.
|
Synergistic
effects of proprioceptive neuromuscular facilitation and manual
lymphatic drainage in patients with mastectomy-related
lymphedema
|
Front Physiol.
2017;8:959
|
Vakharia PP, et al. |
Bibliometric analysis of breast cancer-related
lymphoedema research published from 2007-2016
|
J Lymphoedema. 2017;12(1):16-8 |
Samuel SR, et al. |
Exercise-based
interventions for cancer survivors in India: a systematic review
|
Springerplus.
2015;4(1):655
|
Nicholson R, et al. |
Understanding the acceptability and feasibility of
a regional Lymphoedema surveillance programme: a pilot study
|
J Lymphoedema. 2019;14(1):32-6 |
Chart 1 - Characteristics of the studies selected for the application for
treating post-mastectomized patients with upper limb lymphedema.
Figure 1 - Flowchart of studies’ identification, selection, and inclusion
process, prepared based on the Preferred Reporting Items for
Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA)
recommendation.
Figure 1 - Flowchart of studies’ identification, selection, and inclusion
process, prepared based on the Preferred Reporting Items for
Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA)
recommendation.
The planning and production of didactic content included the definition of topics
and the writing of subjects. For the construction of the application, the media
were selected, as well as the design of the interface (layout). We opted for
using texts, illustrations, and videos structured in topics and connected by
hypertexts (links). The navigation structure was defined, and the environment
configuration was planned.
The tools, educational, and technological resources were configured, as well as
the construction of an environment to download the application on the Internet
and install it on the mobile device.
Then, functionality tests were carried out (usability, performance,
compatibility, and functionality). The testing process was carried out according
to the steps described below:
• Usability testing: to verify that the user can intuitively use the application
from the home screen to the final result. The project’s authors used the
application five times, registering the patient and verifying the
physiotherapeutic treatment procedures in the patient with lymphedema.
• Performance test: The responsiveness after each command performed was
evaluated. During the use of the application, the systems analyst and the
project authors checked the initialization time, screen changes, and application
completion time. The access time to each screen, the time to register a new
patient, and the reading of the physiotherapy treatment procedure were
considered.
• The compatibility test with the theoretical framework was divided into two
phases. First, the test verified information at the semantic and syntactic level
of the application’s content. In the second phase, functional or black-box
testing was used to test the system. The systems analyst conducted this
test.
For the functional test of the application, some devices were chosen that had
Android technology as determinants, characterized by mobile equipment and with
WiFi connectivity available for access to the wireless network to carry out the
usability and compatibility tests. The authors and the systems analyst conducted
the entire testing process.
RESULTS
The application consists of 31 screens, 4 pictures, and 3 videos. The initial
screen contains ” Enter ” icons for registered users or ”Register” for new ones.
When completing the registration (Figure 2a), the user will open the anamnesis screen by clicking ”Next” (Figure 2b). After completing the anamnesis,
the user will be directed to the physical examination screen (Figure 2c), where he can assess the range of
motion with illustrations and instructions on performing the measurement
technique.
Figure 2 - Examples of screens from the Linfedema APP application. Screens
for (a) user registration, (b) completion of anamnesis, and (c)
physical examination.
Figure 2 - Examples of screens from the Linfedema APP application. Screens
for (a) user registration, (b) completion of anamnesis, and (c)
physical examination.
Clicking ”Next” will open the perimetry screen for the patient with UL
lymphedema. After viewing the demonstrative video of the perimetry technique
(Figure 3a), the user can fill in the
data collected in the form fields (Figure 3b) according to the height and segment of the affected limb.
Figure 3 - Examples of screens from the Linfedema APP application. (a)
Demonstration video of the perimetry technique and (b) form for data
collection.
Figure 3 - Examples of screens from the Linfedema APP application. (a)
Demonstration video of the perimetry technique and (b) form for data
collection.
After carrying out the anamnesis, physical examination, and perimetry, and
depending on the results obtained and the characteristics of the skin, the user
will be automatically directed to the treatment indications according to the
degree of clinical staging of the lymphedema (Figure 4). The application offers therapeutic management options for
post-mastectomized patients with MMS lymphedema and indicates preventive care
(Figure 4a, b, and c).
Figure 4 - Examples of screens from the Linfedema APP application. Screens
showing videos for (a) grade 1 treatment, (b) grade 2 treatment, and
(c) preventive care indications for upper limb lymphedema.
Figure 4 - Examples of screens from the Linfedema APP application. Screens
showing videos for (a) grade 1 treatment, (b) grade 2 treatment, and
(c) preventive care indications for upper limb lymphedema.
The application was registered at the National Institute of Industrial Property
(INPI) of the Ministry of Development, Industry, and Foreign Trade and is
available on the Google Play Store under the name ”Linfedema APP.”
DISCUSSION
The choice of theme for the ”Linfedema APP” application arose because of the
difficulties observed by researchers during their clinical practices, in the
sense that some professionals have difficulty in assessing, prescribing
preventive measures and therapeutic management for post-mastectomized patients
with upper limb lymphedema. A previous search was then carried out, which showed
that no application helps or guides the physiotherapist in an evaluation.
Because of this fact, it was decided to develop the ”Linfedema APP” application,
which, after evaluating the patient, will provide professionals with indications
of preventive measures and physiotherapeutic exercises.
In Brazil, the use of management software has grown exponentially in different
areas. In the work process of health professionals, information technology is
increasingly improving through the development and evaluation of tools,
processes, and structures that help these professionals manage care, whether
preventive or therapeutic7,16-18.
Professionals who deal with post-mastectomized patients with upper limb
lymphedema, when using the application developed in this study, will be
acquiring and developing clinical skills, as they will assist with the lowest
possible risk, without damage and adverse events, in short, assistance with
security for post-mastectomized individuals, since this technological instrument
was developed with a scientific basis, through an integrative review of the
literature found in the main databases.
The more clinical information an application provides, the better the
decision-making process. Thus, it is essential to develop technological tools
that make clinical management related to people with post-mastectomy lymphedema
more efficient and minimize the difficulties and deficiencies of health
professionals in clinical practice5,19.
The ”Linfedema APP” application allows physiotherapists, through smartphones,
notebooks, and tablets, quick access to information during the consultation and
clinical evaluation, helping the professional collect data, as the application
provides a report of the entire evaluation and procedures performed. It also
provides videos demonstrating the technique of physiotherapeutic exercises.
An application must have a social impact, offer health professionals theoretical
and practical foundations, as well as standardization of assessment, preventive
measures, therapeutic approaches, and instructions for self-care, which result
in improved care provided to patients, individualized and systematized care,
greater safety for health professionals and patients5,12,20.
With technological advances, mainly in telephone devices, the use of applications
is becoming more and more common; in this way, professionals will make more
informed decisions, following clinical protocols that will be evolutionarily
more effective, providing less chance of error during the clinical
procedure12,20.
CONCLUSION
After an integrative review of the literature in the main databases, the
”Linfedema APP” application was developed, which constitutes a practical tool
to
qualify, direct, and guide the physiotherapist in performing the exercises in
post-mastectomized patients with lymphedema in the upper limbs.
1. Universidade do Vale do Sapucaí, Pouso Alegre,
MG, Brazil
Corresponding author: Geraldo Magela Salomé Av.
Prefeito Tuany Toledo, 470, Pouso Alegre, MG, Brazil., Zip Code: 37550-000.,
E-mail: salomereiki@univas.edu.br