INTRODUCTION
The change in medical advertising regulations, notably represented by the recent CFM
Resolution No. 2,336/231, signals a
substantial transformation in the panorama of medical practice, particularly in
the
field of plastic surgery (PS). This review by the Federal Council of Medicine
now
allows for broader dissemination of medical services, such as the results of
surgical interventions, for which cosmetic surgery is increasingly present in
the
media. Thus, this event sheds light and challenges a deeper understanding of the
relationship between the specialty and the press.
In fact, in an article published in the Revista Brasileira de Cirurgia
Plástica, Coelho et al.2 point out that, in addition to recognizing body dissatisfaction
and sociocultural influence as the most evident factors that lead women to plastic
surgery, the media is also an element present in decisions of this nature. Since
the
authors’ work evaluates this phenomenon in female patients who are not celebrities,
it can be inferred that, in those who are, the influence of the media may be even
more active.
Thus, speculations about interventions on famous people and reports of experiences
are often topics in magazines, newspapers, and social networks. However, despite
such development and scope, apparently, little has been investigated about the
conduct of this group in relation to PSs. In a context in which the boundaries
between the clinical sphere and public exposure are becoming increasingly permeable,
the way in which the popularization of plastic surgery is possibly related to
the
acceptance of celebrities and the non-confidentiality of procedures highlights
the
behavior of public figures in shaping social perceptions about the specialty.
Given that women represent 86.3% of all recipients of cosmetic surgical procedures
worldwide3, the search for
a panel on how female celebrities behave regarding whether or not they make their
cosmetic plastic surgeries public seems legitimate.
OBJECTIVE
Therefore, the objective is to contribute to the development of a reference panel
consisting of real situations of how female celebrities publicly approach their
plastic surgeries in the media.
METHOD
This is a qualitative study with secondary data of the Descriptive-Analytical Essay
type. Data collection was carried out online, considering sources in Portuguese
and
English. Relevant publications from three different nations were found, namely
six
from Brazil, three from the United Kingdom, and one from the United States of
America. In addition, texts written on websites, magazines, and newspapers, as
well
as long and short videos from social networks, were used.
RESULTS
Hiding
During Hollywood’s “golden age” in the 1960s, there were ten rules that movie
stars were required to follow, including changing their appearance, often
through PSs. Such changes were the subject of speculation, as celebrities at
the
time were not likely to speak openly about the topic.
Celebrities, especially female ones, denied that their changes in physical
appearance, when comparing before and after fame, were the result of surgical
interventions. A representative example of this concealment is that of actress
Marilyn Monroe, who never confirmed having undergone PSs. However, 51 years
after her death, X-rays confirmed that she had undergone a chin graft, a
fracture in the nasal bone, and silicone injections in her breasts (a precursor
to today’s breast implants)5.
With the beginning of the new century, it is clear that the public remained with
the idea that famous people who appeared on television, in magazines, and
recently on the Internet were naturally beautiful. Renowned personalities of
the
21st century are still reluctant to publicly admit their plastic surgeries
despite having notable transformations in their physical appearance after
becoming famous.
Another notable example of this phenomenon is the Swiss media personality Jocelyn
Wildenstein, 82, called “cat woman” for her changing appearance; the celebrity
denies having undergone any procedure, even though her appearance reveals
typical characteristics of successive surgical interventions6.
Also, the American reality TV star Kim Kardashian, 42, is another example of this
concealment. In the 2010s, the influencer was reported by the media for
undergoing buttock augmentation with the “Brazilian Butt Lift” (BBL); in 2023,
there was speculation about the reversal of the BBL through
liposuction7. Another
case that gained notoriety in the media was that of the actress Jennifer
Lawrence, 32, who was also the target of speculation. After changes in her
appearance and being named one of the most beautiful people in the world by
People Magazine in 2011, she confirmed, in 2012, the rumors about a rhinoplasty
that had previously been hidden in the past8.
Unveiling
Unlike celebrities such as television personalities and actresses, some openly
expose their surgical procedures. In this sense, the singer Anitta, in 2013,
decided to reveal her first rhinoplasty when receiving the Best of the Year
award on the Domingão do Faustão program on Rede Globo, wearing a bandage on
her
nose9. In this episode,
since PS was still a subject that was not usually discussed so openly, by not
hiding the recovery process, the program’s audience reacted negatively10. The artist seemed not to care
about the criticism and maintained her position of not hiding her aesthetic
interventions.
In Brazil, other famous personalities have also begun to address the issue with
greater transparency, such as presenter Xuxa Meneghel, 60 years old, who shared
her experiences with mammoplasty: the first in 2000, with a 230ml implant, and
the second in 2016, with a reduction to 140ml implants11.
Furthermore, the concept of celebrity, in the past, was limited to people known
for occupying prominent positions, such as in movies, television programs, soap
operas, and plays. In contemporary times, with the relevance of social networks,
it is clear that famous personalities have emerged from the virtual world, such
as digital influencers.
It has become common for patients to post videos on YouTube documenting their own
experiences with plastic surgery. Makeup artist Mari Maria, 30, whose channel
has 10.5 million subscribers, created a series on the platform describing the
preand post-surgery processes of her rhinoplasty, which has 2.6 million views
on
the video showing the day of the surgery12. The images from 2018 were shared with the public the
footage immediately after the procedure, with the influencer still weak.
In this sense of greater popularization and freedom of reporting, there is a
similar movement among TikTok users. Profiles with much engagement publish short
videos describing their experiences and answering followers’ questions about
it.
Influencer Dylan Mulvaney, with 10.6 million followers on the social network,
narrated her process of gender affirmation for the female sex, explaining how
her successive surgeries, such as rhinoplasty, mentoplasty, and frontoplasty,
occurred. In a 2022 post with 17.5 million viewers, for example, the influencer
shows a conversation with her plastic surgeon about facial feminization
surgery13.
DISCUSSION
Consistent evidence indicates that in the past, Plastic Surgery was limited to
contributing to the recovery of patients’ quality of life through reconstructive
procedures, with a change in the specialty’s direction being observed over the
years. In this sense, the 2018 Census of the Brazilian Society of Plastic
Surgery14 shows the
predominance of aesthetic interventions in relation to reconstructive ones, given
that, in the period from 2009 to 2018, aesthetic surgery exceeded the number of
reconstructive procedures in 2018 in Brazil by 359,029.
Furthermore, with regard to the growth of the specialty, an increase of 177.1% was
reported in these ten years of analysis, with an initial 629,000 procedures in
2009
and 1,742,861 in 201814. Thus,
plastic surgery grew as a specialty with the popularization of aesthetic
interventions, a process possibly influenced by the change in the behavior of
celebrities in revealing their surgeries publicly.
Lima et al.15, in a study published
in this journal, highlight that, in fact, the concept of PS conveyed in the media
is
directly associated with aesthetic gains. The authors concluded that of the 1,983
news articles that addressed CPs analyzed in the Brazilian press, 68.94% were
classified with a focus on aesthetics, while 21.33% were in the restorative
area.
Furthermore, from concealment to revelation, it is observed that, nowadays, many
celebrities openly expose their procedures. This observed change in behavior can
promote the affirmation of plastic surgery since it contributes to demystifying
and
popularizing the procedures. Likewise, it is possible to infer that, as they began
to report their aesthetic procedures, PS gained more presence in the media.
Finally, with regard to the limitations of the work, it seems that contrary to what
has been gathered here, a lack of scientific studies can be identified that relate
plastic surgery to patients exposed to the media. In databases such as SciELO,
PubMed, and LILACS, the only article on this discussion was found, the one already
mentioned by Lima et al.15 Thus,
this scarcity points to the need for more studies on the subject to be produced,
which would broaden this current exploration.
CONCLUSION
It can, therefore, be stated that three important changes have been recorded that
seem to be interconnected. The first concerns the popularization of cosmetic
surgery. There has also been a change in the behavior of famous people regarding
their plastic surgeries, from concealment to disclosure. It is important to note
that the reporting of such a change was associated with the greater presence of
plastic surgery in the media, contributing to the promotion of the specialty.
REFERENCES
1. Brasil. Conselho Federal de Medicina. Resolução CFM Nº 2.336/23.
Dispõe sobre publicidade e propaganda médicas [Internet]. [acesso 2023 set 14].
Disponível em: https://sistemas.cfm.org.br/normas/visualizar/resolucoes/BR/2023/2336
2. Coelho FD, Carvalho PHB, Fortes LS, Paes ST, Ferreira MEC. Body
dissatisfaction and influence of media in women who undergo plastic surgery.
Rev
Bras Cir Plást. 2015;30(4):567-73.
3. http://www.isaps.org
4. L’Officiel Brasil. 10 regras que as estrelas da antiga Hollywood
precisavam seguir [Internet]. [acesso 2023 ago 23]. Disponível em: https://www.revistalofficiel.com.br/cultura/10-regras-que-as-estrelas-da-antiga-hollywood-precisavam-seguir
5. Vogue Brasil. O mistério das cirurgias plásticas de Marilyn Monroe é
finalmente revelado [Internet]. [acesso 2023 ago 26]. Disponível em: https://vogue.globo.com/beleza/noticia/2013/10/o-misterio-das-cirurgias-plasticas-de-marilyn-monroe-e-finalmente-revelado.ghtml
6. Saunt R. So it’s all just smoke and mirrors? As Catwoman Jocelyn
Wildenstein once AGAIN claims she’s ‘never had plastic surgery’, FEMAIL reveals
the other ever-evolving stars who insist they’ve NEVER been under the knife
[Internet]. Daily Mail. 2013 Feb 25 [acesso 2023 ago 26]. Disponível em:
https://www.dailymail.co.uk/femail/article-11786299/The-celebrities-denied-having-plastic-surgery.html
7. MYA Cosmetic Surgery. Has Kim Kardashian had cosmetic surgery?
[Internet]. [acesso 2023 ago 26]. Disponível em: https://www.mya.co.uk/mya-social/blog/kim-kardashian-cosmetic-surgery
8. MYA Cosmetic Surgery. Has Jennifer Lawrence had cosmetic surgery?
[Internet]. [acesso 2023 ago 26]. Disponível em: https://www.mya.co.uk/mya-social/blog/jennifer-lawrence-cosmetic-surgery
9. ESG. Anitta toda remendada no palco do Faustão. Melhores do ano
2013. [Internet]. [acesso 2023 ago 26]. Disponível em: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C7Jdvyd1MSw
10. Veja São Paulo. Anitta vai ao Faustão com curativo de cirurgia
plástica, é criticada na internet e desabafa: “Não tô nem aí” [Internet].
[acesso 2023 ago 26]. Disponível em: https://vejasp.abril.com.br/coluna/pop/anitta-vai-ao-faustao-com-curativo-de-cirurgia-plastica-e-criticada-na-internet-e-desabafa-8220-nao-to-nem-ai-8221
11. Vasconcelos DF. Entenda a cirurgia plástica de redução de mama feita
por Xuxa Meneghel [Internet]. [acesso 2023 ago 26]. Disponível em: https://drfredericovasconcelos.com.br/entenda-a-cirurgia-plastica-de-reducao-demama-feita-por-xuxa-meneghel/
12. Maria M. Fiz rinoplastia! [Internet]. [acesso 2023 ago 26].
Disponível em: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VyiSo6NvBeo
13. Mulvaney D. Day 172 - ffs consult with @facialplastic/reconstructive
[Internet]. [acesso 2023 ago 26]. Disponível em: https://www.tiktok.com/@dylanmulvaney/video/7137782539992796458?_t=8eTq2WY1XnC&_r=1
14. Sociedade Brasileira de Cirurgia Plástica (SBCP). Censo 2018,
análise comparativa das pesquisas 2014, 2016 e 2018 [Internet]. [acesso 2023
ago
25]. Disponível em: http://www2.cirurgiaplastica.org.br/wp-content/uploads/2019/08/Apresentação-Censo-2018_V3.pdf
15. Lima DSC, Mata FSR, Oliveira FCC, Zenaide PV, Ziomkowski AA, Meneses
JVL. Plastic surgery in the media: the concept of the specialty, as reported
by
the print media in Brazil. Rev Bras Cir Plást.
2015;30(1):93-100.
1. Pontifícia Universidade Católica de Campinas,
Faculdade de Medicina, Campinas, SP, Brazil
Lucas Monteiro Chaves José
Decourt Homem de Mello, S/N, Res. Estância Eudóxia, Campinas, SP, Brazil, Zip
Code: 130855-552, E-mail: lucasmonteirochaves1903@gmail.com
Artigo submetido: 29/01/2024.
Artigo aceito: 26/07/2024.
Conflicts of interest: none.