INTRODUCTION
The use of ear lobe extenders is a widespread habit, especially among adolescents.
Such devices cause a deformity in the ear lobe, with enlargement and circular holes.
Several techniques have already been described and are currently used to close such
defects. Mostly, different local flap techniques are used as a tool for lobe repair1,2,3.
We propose to present a new correction option, simpler, faster, and cheaper, using
trichloroacetic acid to close these lesions.
Trichloroacetic acid (TCA) in high concentrations induces necrosis of all layers of
the epidermis, reaching the papillary dermis, followed by the reconstitution of the
epidermis and the matrix of the papillary dermis, through wound healing processes4,5.
TCA has cytotoxic effects, such as suppressing the proliferation of keratinocytes
and fibroblasts and the synthesis of proteins by fibroblasts, but its biological mechanism
is not yet fully understood6.
TCA-treated skin stimulates platelets, monocytes and keratinocytes to produce different
growth factors, including PDGF-B transiently. The platelet-derived growth factor stimulates
tissue fibroblasts around the wound to proliferate, express the appropriate integrin
receptors and migrate into the wound space and thus, presumably, increase wound closure
by stimulating reepithelization7.
Keratinocytes treated with TCA expressed IL-1 (pro-inflammatory) and IL-10 (anti-inflammatory)
depending on TCA concentrations, which were regulated after treatment, which suggests
that the inflammatory reaction after treatment with TCA is well balanced, resulting
in a better cosmetic result4.
METHODS
After using TCA 90% frequently for closing partial fissures in ear lobes, we decided
to evaluate its action in patients with sequelae due to the use of skin eyelets.
We selected four patients with previous use of ear skin eyelets bilaterally, and 1
with unilateral injury and intent to close (Table 1), to assess the feasibility of the technique. First, the patients were instructed
regarding the procedure and signed a free and informed consent term. Asepsis was performed
with alcoholic chlorhexidine, followed by the application of a single uniform layer
of 90% TCA, with the aid of a cotton swab or wooden toothpick. After application,
the frosting was observed, noting a solid white layer, covering the entire internal
surface of the hole. A dressing with micropore was performed, approaching the edges
of the lesion (Figure 1). Patients were instructed on local care and scheduled weekly follow-up visits.
Table 1 - Relationship between age, affected side, sex, usage time and skin eyelet diameter.
|
Age |
Side |
Gender |
Usage time |
Diameter |
Pacient 1 |
14 |
Bilateral |
Feminine |
2 years |
30 mm |
Pacient 2 |
29 |
Bilateral |
Masculine |
10 years |
18 mm |
Pacient 3 |
29 |
Bilateral |
Feminine |
8 years |
18 mm |
Pacient 4 |
22 |
Bilateral |
Feminine |
7 years |
16 mm |
Pacient 5 |
16 |
Left |
Masculine |
2 years |
26 mm |
Table 1 - Relationship between age, affected side, sex, usage time and skin eyelet diameter.
Figure 1 - A. Patient with skin eyelets; B. Patient without skin eyelets; C. After immediate application of TCA; D. 2 weeks after application; E. 1 month after application; F. 2 months after application; G. 4 months after application; H. 1 year after application.
Figure 1 - A. Patient with skin eyelets; B. Patient without skin eyelets; C. After immediate application of TCA; D. 2 weeks after application; E. 1 month after application; F. 2 months after application; G. 4 months after application; H. 1 year after application.
RESULTS
After applying the product, hyperemia was observed around the area where the acid
was applied, followed by frosting. The frosting area was replaced by a crust in a
few days and loosened over time, concomitantly reducing the diameter of the lesion.
Patients were evaluated weekly with a photographic record to document their progress.
Complete closure of the lesions was observed in moments, as described in Table 2. In just one patient, it was necessary to reapply the product, which was done at
4-week intervals. The lobes regained an aesthetically pleasing shape. There was a
coaptation of the edges concentrically, returning a rounded shape to the lobes with
a central scar (Figure 2).
Table 2 - Relationship between closing time and number of applications.
|
Closing time |
No. of applications |
Pacient 1 |
3 weeks |
1 |
Pacient 2 |
2 weeks |
1 |
Pacient 3 |
2 weeks |
1 |
Pacient 4 |
2 weeks |
1 |
Pacient 5 |
12 weeks |
3 |
Table 2 - Relationship between closing time and number of applications.
Figure 2 - A. Patient with skin eyelets; B. Patient without skin eyelets, with a defect in the lobe of the right ear; C. After immediate application of TCA; D. 2 weeks after application; E. 2 months after application; F. 1 year after application.
Figure 2 - A. Patient with skin eyelets; B. Patient without skin eyelets, with a defect in the lobe of the right ear; C. After immediate application of TCA; D. 2 weeks after application; E. 2 months after application; F. 1 year after application.
DISCUSSION
The use of 90% TCA proved to be a simple and effective option for closing enlarged
ear lobes. It can be an excellent alternative to surgeries for correction, which requires
operative time, surgical material, and has a higher cost.
The procedure can be performed in the office, in a few minutes, without the need for
surgical or auxiliary material. The cost of the procedure is low, and there is no
need for anesthesia or any other additional material. Patients do not need to be away
from work activities. We, therefore, understand that this is an up-and-coming technique
for resolving a frequent complaint in our offices.
CONCLUSION
Although our sample is not significant enough to create a clinical approach, the use
of TCA to correct ear lobe elongation has proved to be a low-risk, economical procedure
that does not require a surgical environment for its execution. Further studies are
needed to evaluate its effectiveness in different scenarios of lobuloplasty caused
by using skin eyelets.
COLLABORATIONS
JGS
|
Conception and design study, Methodology, Project Administration, Realization of operations
and/or trials, Supervision, Writing - Original Draft Preparation
|
DOT
|
Conceptualization, Data Curation, Investigation, Methodology, Project Administration,
Writing - Review & Editing
|
JP
|
Analysis and/or data interpretation, Supervision
|
ACN
|
Data Curation, Methodology
|
CP
|
Analysis and/or data interpretation, Data Curation
|
FGM
|
Analysis and/or data interpretation, Methodology, Project Administration
|
RPG
|
Analysis and/or data interpretation, Final manuscript approval, Project Administration
|
REFERENCES
1. Pek WS, Goh LHT, Pek CH. The rolling earlobe flap for dilated ear holes following
ear gauging: a novel approach to aesthetically preserving earlobe soft tissue. Arch
Plast Surg. 2017 Sep;44(5):453-6.
2. Collins J, Harvey J, Hilinski JM. Reconstructing the gauge earlobe defect. JAMA Facial
Plast Surg. 2015 Mar/Apr;17(2):144-8.
3. Snell BJ, Caplash Y. A novel way to repair the earlobe after ear-gauging. J Plast
Reconstr Aesthet Surg. 2013 Jan;66(1):140-1.
4. Kimura A, Kanazawa N, Li JH, Yonei N, Yamamoto Y, Furukawa F. Influence of chemical
peeling on the skin stress response system, Exp Dermatol. 2012 Jul;(21 Suppl 1):8-10.
5. Nguyen TH, Rooney JA. Trichloroacetic acid peels. Dermatol Ther. 2000;13(2):173-82.
6. Rakic L, Lapière CM, Nusgens BV. Skin. Pharmacol Appl Skin Physiol. 2000;13:52-9.
7. Yonei N, Kanazawa N, Ohtani T, Furukawa F, Yamamoto Y. Induction of PDGF-B in TCA-treated
epidermal keratinocytes. Arch Dermatol Res. 2007 Nov;299(9):433-40.
1. Hospital Irmãos Penteado, Serviço de Cirurgia Plástica Professor Dr. Ricardo Baroudi,
Campinas, SP, Brazil.
Corresponding author: Juliana Gulelmo Staut, Carlos Eduardo Correia de Negreiros, 50, Campinas, SP, Brazil. Zip Code: 13049-352.
E-mail: jgstaut@gmail.com
Article received: November 08, 2019.
Article accepted: February 22, 2020.
Conflicts of interest: none.